Firehouse Subs already has a solid fan base for its hot and tasty sandwiches. But behind the main menu lies something only some of the most loyal fans know about – the secret menu.
The secret menu items are not random customizations. They are full-blown creations with unique identities.
On the secret menu, Firehouse Subs offers upgraded classics, bold flavor mashups, and many other items to level up your eating experience.
Scroll up to learn more about the Firehouse Subs secret menu:
What Exactly Is a Secret Menu at Firehouse Subs?
The Firehouse Subs secret menu is not official, but it’s real. You won’t find a published “secret menu” online or in-store.
However, some top fans have developed a creative combination that has gained traction among fans and staff alike.
These items are made with ingredients that are already in the store. This means you can fully customize your meal to be one of the top secret menu items, even if you don’t see it on the board. Provided you know what you want, you can ask them to create it.
Firehouse Subs does not have a secret handshake. But knowing the item’s name and how to describe it helps a lot.
If you’re lucky, employees can easily recognize the name. Other times, you will have to walk them through the build.
7 Top Secret Menu Items That Will Surprise You
Trust me, these are not your regular or average subs. They each bring something unique to the table.
-
Smokehouse Beef & Cheddar Brisket
I recommend the Smokehouse Beef & Cheddar Brisket for those who are craving something smoky and indulgent. It hits hard all the time. Firehouse Subs makes this special item with:
- Chopped smoked brisket
- Sweet Baby Ray’s BBQ Sauce
- Melted cheddar cheese
- Toasted white or wheat sub roll
If you have allergy issues, I recommend you opt for the toasted white sub roll instead of the white sub roll. This sub is everything you love about BBQ in sandwich form.
-
Sweet & Spicy Meatball
When you want to order in-store, just tell the employee you want the Sweet & Spicy Meatball, and they’ll know what to do. It’s a level up of the original meatball. They make it with:
- Italian meatballs
- Spicy cherry pepper relish
- Firehouse’s sweet mustard sauce
- Melted provolone cheese
You will love the blend of spicy, sweet, and savory, making it a meal you’ll want to try multiple times.
-
Chicken Bacon Ranch (CBR)
Firehouse Subs has a standard chicken sub. The Chicken Bacon Ranch is different. It’s more of a comfort food. Firehouse Sub makes this special item with the following ingredients:
- Crispy bacon
- Grillee chicken breast
- Lettuce and tomato
- Creamy ranch dressing
- Cheddar cheese
It’s more like an upgraded version of the standard chicken sub. Ask them to toast it to make it the cheese extra melty.
-
The New Yorker
Firehouse Subs didn’t hold back anything when making this sub. It goes full deli-style. Included in The New Yorker are:
- Corned beef brisket
- Pastrami
- Mayo and deli mustard
- Melted provolone
- Italian dressing drizzle
What makes me love it more is how satisfying it is. It’s flavorful and would keep you coming back for more. And yes, it’s messy in the best way.
-
The Firehouse Hero Remix
This is one item many customers have not tried yet. It’s a level up of the original Hero sandwich. You’ll love this sandwich better when paired with the right side and drink. Firehouse Subs makes it with:
- Roast beef
- Smoked turkey breast
- Provolone
- Hot peppers
- Honey ham
- Cajun mustard (upon request)
They can add or remove ingredients to suit your unique needs. This upgrade adds serious spice and flavor to this sandwich.
-
Buffalo Chicken Melt
The Buffalo Chicken Melt is for you if you’re a spice enthusiast. This sub features a unique set of ingredients that create a fiery yet balanced flavor. Those ingredients are:
- Sliced grilled chicken
- Buffalo sauce
- Toasted sub roll
- Ranch or bleu cheese dressing
- Lettuce and tomato
Want a serious kick? Tell them to go all hard on the buffalo sauce. Just make sure you’re capable of handling the heat.
-
The California
If you’re looking for something light but still flavorful, I recommend The California. It’s made with some of the best ingredients in the house, such as:
- Slicked turkey
- Avocado
- Pepper Jack cheese
- Firehouse sauce
- Lettuce, onion, and tomato
How to Order a Secret Menu Item Without Confusion
Remember, Firehouse Subs does not have a dedicated secret menu. The secret menu is just a list of highly customized menu items. But many don’t know about them. Here are the simple steps for ordering off the secret menu.
Step 1: Know the Build
The first step to ordering from this menu is knowing what you want. Know the item name and ingredients.
Not every employee is familiar with items like The California. But they will know what to do if you tell them you want turkey with avocado, pepper jack, lettuce, Firehouse sauce, and tomato.
Step 2: Be Friendly, Not Pushy
These items are not officially on the menu. You’re asking for a highly customized sub, so politeness goes a long way. Be clear and respectful with your request to make the employee happy, and respond to your request swiftly.
Step 3: Confirm Add-On Costs
Since you’re ordering something other than the regular menu item, most things will cost extra. Extra meat, avocado, and some other ingredients may incur upcharges.
Always double-check the final price before paying, especially after making several changes to the order.
Wrapping Up
If you thought Firehouse Subs was great already, just wait until you try the secret menu. These hidden sandwiches bring creativity, variety, and flavor combinations that go way beyond the usual.
You don’t need special access – just the right words and a little curiosity. So next time you walk in, don’t just order what’s on the board. Go off-menu. You might just find your new favorite.
